Rob Shocks Compares Pocock, Pstack and Osmani Agent Skill Packs

Rob Shocks released a video comparing three agent skill packs: Matt Pocock's Skills For Real Engineers, Addy Osmani's Agent Skills and the Cursor plugin pstack. He concluded that no single pack wins universally, with Pocock focused on alignment, Osmani on the full engineering lifecycle and pstack on proving that work actually runs, and advised matching skill ceremony to risk rather than installing every pack.
Event version 1.
Key insights
No universal skill pack winner
The comparison found no single pack that wins across all cases. Pocock asks whether the team is building the same thing, Osmani asks whether the full engineering lifecycle was followed, and pstack asks whether the work can be proven to run.
Osmani's six-stage SDLC
Addy Osmani's pack condenses the classic SDLC into six agent stages: Define, Plan, Build, Verify, Review and Ship. It includes about 25 skills, multiple reviewer personas and anti-rationalization tables that rebut common excuses.
Doubt-driven development
Osmani emphasizes doubt-driven development: important decisions are written as short claims, reasoning is stripped away, a fresh context looks for flaws, and fixes are reconciled over a limited number of rounds.
Ceremony should match risk
Rob Shocks advised against installing a full skill set on every project because it floods context and can trigger skills unintentionally. He recommended light, medium and heavy configurations and borrowing individual skills rather than running two main routers in parallel.